2010 Porsche Cayman

Price Range: $51,400 - $61,500

Although the Cayman might not be quite as fast as other exotics, it provides one of the best sports-car driving experiences, with critically lauded steering and handling and costs less than Porsche's own flagship 911 Carrera. With good cargo space, respectable fuel economy and decent driver and passenger comfort, it makes more everyday sense than a number of other performance-oriented machines.